Axel from blog-n97.fr contacted me yesterday to let me know he'd finished his review on the N97. Though it's in French, but he's given me permission to translate it fully in to English, so here it is.
Introduction
The Nokia N97 that I had the chance to test is still in Beta, the firmware is not a production version. I'm sure the bugs and any slow downs will be resolved before the final release. WiFi used was not very good quality (relatively low signal).
When I filmed this test (excluding applications), it was about 6 am after a short night, so I may sound a little bored, but I was just tired! though very excited to test out the beast. Normally I'd use a tripod for the filming, but it was too heavy to take to the hotel.
This is obviously a white Nokia N97.
Unpacking and contents of the box
N97 The box is black with a matt finish, it's rather nice. The top of the box shows the name of the phone "Nokia N97" written in silver and an embossed drawing of N97. The side of the box also has silver writing. Overall the box has a very high end feel.
Upon opening the box, the phone is presented at the top, in a black plastic tray and comes with a stylus type "USB key" (though smaller) which is very practical.
N97 demo video (in french) but provides a great insight in to the handset.
Contents of the box:
Classic Nokia Hands-free
USB / Micro-USB Cable
Charger AC-10E micro-USB
Charger adapter micro USB to Nokia classic charger
Standard Nokia headset
Cleaning cloth
CD containing Ovi Suite Package
User Manual
No TV cable, we will verify that.
External appearance of the N97
The N97 is compact despite its keyboard and its hinge. No game is detectable which is really nice and reassuring. It holds very well in hand as a whole and not as a phone in two parts. You can easily manipulate the phone one-handed through the design of the phone (eg with 5800 I have a little trouble with the stick to a hand).
The screen is 3.5" widescreen (16:9) (the screen would usually be brighter but in the images there's a screen protector covering the screen). At the top of the phone you'll see the proximity sensor is square with rounded edges (quite large), the earpiece for voice calls, for the video camera and light sensor. The Nokia logo is displayed in the chrome bezel at the top right of the phone. At the bottom of the phone you'll see the menu button (silver) and the red and green buttons to start and end a call, they're touch sensitive.
Over on the left side you'll see the stereo speakers, button lock / unlock which is very handy to prevent accidental key presses. And micro-USB port.
On the top, you'll see the "power" and the 3.5 mm jack / TV output. Over on the right side, volume (+ and -) and the camera button and below the microphone for voice calls or audio input. The back of the phone features the Tessar Carl Zeiss optics 5 megapixel with Dual LED video light (which I could not test it, forgive me, sorry). Access to the battery is as usual behind the rear shell.
The main material is plastic, but very good quality plastic. The screen is also made from plastic, but much thicker than that of the 5800. The outer edge of the phone features an attractive chrome bezel.
The hinge is perfect, see the video and pictures, it opens and closes with easy with a very nice solid swing and no noise. The hinge may get dust in it, so please check from time to time. Axel Meyer from Nokia confirms dust wont effect the performance of the hinge. Once closed the phone feels very solid. The 40 degree angle of the hinge allows for a very cool video playback.
The QWERTY keyboard is also made of plastic, the keys are slightly raised, allowing for easy key press. The space bar is on the right (a little difficult at first but with a little help is very useful) and there are directional arrows to the left. On the white version, the letters are in gray and "functions" in blue.
When you use the keypad it lights up and the effect is quite nice. Please note that in this unofficial release, all the letters are not illuminated with the same intensity and there is also some leakage of light above the keyboard (see photo). There call and hang button don't suffer from any light leakage. The keys when pressed make a pleasant noise.
Homescreen widgets
The phone starts up quickly with a light and vibration. The HomeScreen is rather enjoyable to watch (here with a blue theme). The content of the widgets can take a long time to load but again this isn't a final release and so it could be much faster in the final release.
You can move the widgets, remove and add. The placement of widgets is quite intuitive and the system is reactive.
The N97 has an accelerometer which allows the phone to automatically adjust, depending on the orientation of the handset. Transitions are very fast.
By default you have access to contacts and numbering on the home page (in addition to the "Options"), the numbering is good, with large keys.
A long press of the menu button opens the window menu to display open applications, from this window you can close an application or open it.
Preinstalled Widgets
AccuWeather: Weather widgets
Agenda: display rapid appointment and duties
Amazon: access to amazon catalog
AP News: Associated Press, recent news
Bloomberg: latest news
Contacts 1 and 2 Favorites: Quick access to contacts
FM Transmitter: quick access to the FM transmitter
Hi5: we need an account, a priori, but quick access to the application Hi5 and display the latest events
Player audio: audio player on the HomeScreen
Online sharing: quick online sharing
Shortcut 1 and 2: shortcuts to some applications
Slideshow: Reuters latest news with pictures (a slide show)
Embed e-mail: configure e-mail, then displays the latest e-mails received
Facebook: view the latest events and quick application to Facebook
You can also display the time (digital and analog, direct access to the confirguration the time and alarm), date (with direct access to the agenda) and the mode (quick mode changes, as the "power").
Menu, Messages and Calendar
Pressing the "menu" takes you to the main menu, it displays the same icons as 5800 by default, the new icons from Nokia which are quite beautiful, I think. You see the calendar, contacts, music, web browser, messaging, photos, Ovi Store (shop), Nokia Maps (Maps), videos and TV settings, games and applications.
In options, you always show open applications above and then display list (see the menu items in a list rather than grid view by default), Organize (to move the icons in the manner of HomeScreen, very practical and intuitive), Help, and Exit (exit takes you to the home page).
The agenda is more conventional but very handy on the big screen of the N97, you have several displays, by month, week or day (accessed through the icons below). Entering an appointment or task is very fast with the physical keyboard and quick access.
Messaging is very much like the 5800, New Message, Inbox, e-mail (you must configure an e-mail), Sent Mail, Drafts, Outbox, Delivery and My Folders. The interest lies in patterns of attachment to post a message: alphanumeric keyboard (tactile), handwriting (well run) and, of course, the physical QWERTY keyboard.
In general, the scroll in the menus can be done in two ways: by using the scroll bar on the side or by touching an item in the list and dragging it down. The scroll bar works well, though isn't exceptional and we would have liked to see the kinetic scrolling (like on an iPhone or Android).
Last, in some menus you just touch it once to open the option, sometimes twice. There are several reasons, sometimes you need to select files or elements (for example in the photo gallery), where double-clicking. In addition, this feature is inherent in Symbian 5th edition. However sometimes the lack of logic in this system, where it is sometimes double-clicking in lists where a single click would have been possible (music for example, to browse through artists, etc.). Some people think that double-clicking allows scrolling by touching icons but scrolling mode is already present in the menus of applications (for example) but is simple click.
Photo & Video
Taking a photo is very simple, you can either open the camera cover which turns the camera on, or you can press and hold the camera button. The shutter speed is very fast and the pictures are of good quality with its Carl Zeiss optics. There are lots of options presented on the screen just to adjust your shot (zoom, flash, macro, white settings, etc).
Once the photo taken, you can easily share via MMS, e-mail, bluetooth and the sharing tools online available (Flickr, Ovi and other services).
Navigation in the photos is quick and makes use of the accelerometer. To move from one image to another, a flick of the finger to the right or left to zoom in double-tap the screen or use the zoom bar on the left side of the screen.
To take a video, it is the same process except that you select "Video mode" in the application. To start shooting, you have to press the red button "record". The N97 records in 16:9, which is simply brilliant. The large screen provides a perfect view. Contrary to what is said in the video, you can shoot with the LED on, simply select the "bulb" before filming.
Web Browser
Web browsing on the N97 is enjoyable thanks to the big 3.5" screen. The browser supports scroll kinetics (taking into account the strength of the scroll) and responds quickly. In the video you'll notice that youtube does not yet work, do not worry, on my E71 and N95 Youtube in desktop mode works perfectly, imagine how awesome it will be on the big N97 screen. The N97 supports flash, it is expected, just not fully implemented in the version I tested.
On the right of the browser you have several options, the first icon on the right (3 lines) opens a shortcuts window, very practical. The second icon allows you to change the site by entering a new web address, then just zoom (via a small bar and - you can also zoom in / zoom out by double-tapping the screen). The last option is ... "options" to display all available options (the button shortcuts presents the main functions of the menu) including the search in the page or viewing options.
The N97's web browser also includes a RSS reader.
Music Player
Video and music are a strong point of the N97. Why? Massive 32GB storage, 3.5" jack and nice music player!
With 32GB (expandable via Micro SD, upto 48gb) about 420 albums. A good package of music! The 3.5mm jack lets you connect your favorite headphones.
The music players simple yet effective. The tracks are sorted in different ways, Artists, Albums, Playlists, All songs, Podcasts, Genres and Composers. If the song has album art, it will be displayed in the list as as well as the playback view, big buttons let you move forward / backward and play / pause. You can adjust the volume with the volume buttons on the side of the device.
The menu "options" in the drive provides access to playback modes (random, etc.), the FM transmitter (the magic that allows you to send your music to car radio or any other radio in fact), EQ (pre-defined modes) , parameters, options to manage the playlist and use the track ring.
Nokia Maps
It's difficult to test the maps locked in a room. But I was able to manipulate the interface in its non-final form and here is what I think.
Nokia Maps load quickly, very quickly, which is really great because it's been a negative aspect to this application. The maps are beautiful and accurate! In my version, the finger scrolling is really slow, I guess this problem will be corrected quickly and knowing Nokia!
The red button on the top right of the map allows you to focus on its position in the video button does not work because I was not LBS.
All the interface is controlled via the touchscreen, you can search directly by selecting the "zoom" and using the zoom bar + / - to the left of the screen. In the options you can change the mode of the map (map, satellite and ground, which shows the terrain, not visible in the video because I'm in a town!) Favorites (to launch quickly navigate to your usual places), the history, traffic information (practice), tools (to connect to the network, move the map in 3D mode (not bad), deactivating the positioning, turn off the compass (on the phone to always show the true north), take a screenshot, settings), dash, shop, and licenses (to purchase licenses if yours is expired) ...
Expect a much more comprehensive test right out of the beast!
Ovi Store
The Ovi application of the N97 is great. Objectively, I believe that the application is very high quality and has enormous potential. Let me explain.
In my view, the potential for a smartphone today is largely in the applications and possibilities that are offered by the device. A good OS with good hardware will make a good phone. A good OS with good hardware and applications accessible easily and quickly, provides an excellent smartphone. Just look at Apples iPhone.
Nokia has a huge challenge: to distinguish it from the app store by apple, or at least get to the same level.
Entering the heart of the Ovi N97 Store (called "Store" in the icons) will start quickly, you can browse the catalog without having an account but it is essential to have an Ovi account to download software. The software is classified under several classes available at the top of the screen: Suggestions (recommanded, depending on the products you have already downloaded, Ovi Store offers products that may interest you), Personalization (wallpapers, ringtones , etc.), Audio & Video (trailers, various videos, pay-series (speed racer in several episodes in the video), sounds ...), Games and Applications.
When you're connected and you open a book, you can download the product, send the page to a friend, check the rating and description, write a review and read the opinions of others.
If you click on download to download the file directly. During the download you can continue browsing in the store (or do something else with Ovi Store in the background). Once the download is complete, the application offers a menu based on the product downloaded: set as wallpaper (for a screen), set in tone (for ringtones), watch / listen ( for sounds and movies) and install (for applications and games) during installation you can continue to navigate the application. The installation is complete, you can even launch it from the Store.
Video and TV
It is difficult for me to talk about the "TV" of N97, as I could not test this feature and will therefore not dwell on the phone's video player.
With 32GB of memory you can store about 45 movies (at a rate of 700MB per movie), 5 full seasons of your favorite shows. The battery should last about 4.5 hours with continuous video playback. Which is great for a phone.
The 16:9 screen makes video playback a pleasure. Then of course you have the 40 degree hinge which further enhances the viewing.
Navigation in a video file is done directly with your finger on the touch screen with a progress bar playback, to pause or manage the same thing (for the volume you can also use the buttons) .
The N97 can also configure the video stream, to view podcasts mobility for example.
Games
The N97 is also an interesting device for games. Its design allows you to play with either the touchscreen or with the arrows on the left side of the QWERTY.
The Ngage application is not installed by default but you can download it. Otherwise, to play, download games on Ovi Store, the catalog is still small at the moment but will grow quickly!
I tested a pre-installed, game Guitar Rock Tour, Guitar Hero. For those not familiar with the concept, it's a game of rhythm and speed, tapping the notes at the correct time. Very cool and popular game.
Applications
This is where it becomes both complex and interesting. There are many applications pre-installed in the N97, namely (some phone functions, others are third party applications):
Notes
Clock (with a widget)
Camera
Office (allows you to edit and create Word, Excel and Powerpoint)
Search function
Online sharing (to share your files across multiple platforms, including very practical coupled to the camera to quickly share your photos on Flickr for example) (has a widget)
Recorder (dictaphone)
Help
Real Player
Location (GPS gives ccordonnées)
My Nokia (requires account)
"Welcome"
Update
Message Reader
Call Log
Configuration Wizard
Podcasting
Access configuration
About
Download
Draw (quite nice, even to the finger!)
FM transmitter (transmit audio via the phone's FM on a car for example) (has a widget)
Joiku Spot (turn your phone 3G WiFi terminal, attention to outside package)
"Traveler"
Youtube
AccuWeather (has a widget)
Amazon (with a widget)
Associated Press News (with a widget)
Bloomberg (has a widget)
Facebook (with a widget)
Hi5 (has a widget)
Reuters Slideshow (has a widget)
Boingo (WiFi utility)
QIK (Live broadcast what you shoot)
Guitar Rock Tour (games are also displayed here)
Out of the phone or when we have tested for a longer period and final version, we will complete testing of each application.
It's quite strange that in "Applications", "Camera" is present but not "Ovi Store, which is itself an application. In all cases, you can move icons and save an application that you like especially in the first screen menu or the shortcuts in Quick's homepage!
Conclusion
How are we already at the conclusion?. Rest assured: this test is only the beginning of a long series of more thorough testing of the N97, when we have a final version in hand, we will make detailed tests of each party, pushing the N97 to its limits.
In the present state of things, namely to have tested a non-final version of the N97, please see the table below with the positive and negative points of the phone.
Positive Points
Negative
Quality of finish
Physical keyboard, hinge system
HomeScreen system and widgets
InternalMemory up 42GB
Ovi Store
Wide screen 16:9
3.5 mm jack
Touch screen technology chosen: some may think that resistive technology is less efficient than the capacitive.It is a question of how to use (with sub without stylus, etc.)
Interface: single click / double click,difficult to understand at the beginning
Interface: scrolling via the scroll bar or by dragging the icons, no finger scroll in the list directly
Sim Free: 699 Euros (Europe), £499 (UK) and $699 (US)
Special thanks to Axel from Blog N97 France for allowing us to translate this in to English
...
awesome review!!!! congrats on your new phone.... dude... can you plz tell me how much RAM is free on startup ..??? and how about the RAM usage form the additional s/w like the desktop widgets ?? thanks...
...
I am really surprised that none of the carriers in the US want anything to do with it. AT&T seems intent on keeping the iphone and T-Mobile wants to focus on android.
...
i was wondering if you could tell me where exactly the stylus would go.. b/c the phone does not appear to have that option but the strap looks too small to fit on the wrist of the owner.. so i was wondering if you might have some insight...
...
thanks... i had gone through the photos and didnt see anywhere that might be a possiblity other than the bottom of the phone but due to the angle i wasnt sure.
E-mail retrival on N97
I have a question regarding E-mail on the N97. I use a pop E-mail account on my E90 and the phone is set-up to retrieve my E-mail automatically every 30 minutes. I woulde prefer shorter intervals (every 10 minutes) but that is not possible on the E90.
What are the automatic E-mail retrival settings on the N97?
...
Honestly? I don't know how I feel about my N97. Having the physical keyboard is nice and so is the home screen. But things I took for granted with using the iPhone just aren't on the N97. For example, I'm used to being able to open my email and see the email as it was intended for me to see. With the N97, only the text shows and no images. The web browser on the iPhone, in my opinion, is better. I haven't been able to get a video to play properly and the OVI store is difficult to navigate. I've been watching this phone for months and paid $700 to get the phone but I'm seriously considering returning it although it will cost me a 15% restocking fee. I'm going to give it a couple of more days to see if it grows on me. I really hope it grows on me but right now I'm a bit disappointed.
...
I've had more time with the device and it is growing on me. The web browser is decent. It is different than the iPhone but I can actually view more content that I couldn't see before. I called Nokia support to ask questions about my other issues/concerns:
1- N-Gage: One of the big reasons I wanted this phone was because it was an N-series phone and I wanted access to the N-Gage games. However, the N-Gage website does not include the N97 as a compatible device. The Nokia rep told me that the N97 is an OVI phone and that Nokia intends to merge N-Gage with OVI. So until they do so I cannot play any of the N-Gage games.
2 - Email: He confirmed that none of the Nokia devices allow images to be displayed in an email. I guess I'll just have to give that up.
3 - Connectivity issues with the Mac - I have a Mac and all of my contacts and calendar events are on the Mac (and iPhone). PC Suites is not compatible with Mac but he told me to connect via a USB cable and select mass storage to move my contacts and calendar. I'm at work now so I will try this when I get home.
4 - Music/Video - He confirmed that I will be able to move my iTunes stuff to the N97 via USB and select multimedia as the transfer option. I'll try this tonight.
So bottom line, it looks like the majority of my issues are fixable and the phone is growing on me.
Nokia N97 worries
Ok, Just a few points to raise, Build quality ? poor, three main reasons. First: light leakage on the black model I own. light leakage at the bottom of the screen, near green and red buttons on front, then also on rear when slid open. light comes through the (chrome) surround on the back of phones screen, also light leakage around right side hinge. Hinges? I read plenty of reviews saying "solid". rubbish, When open the phone has free play around 2mm on the right side, solid on the left though. But strange when open the navi button is on the right, which I believe will make this free play worse over time. The key board ? ok, feedback could be better, no sure click just a soft spungy feeling, Another poor thing is the keyboard lights. buttons E,D,X,arrow up, K and M are not as bright as the others. touch screen feedback is so poor because vibrate is more of a noise than a feeling. In the hand ? it creaks lots, creaks all the time when in use, feels cheap. Navi button has lots of free play before hitting the micro switch underneath. The software is another story for another time. Mine was bought through Phones 4 U in Weston super mare in July 2009. Since owning it I have carried out all updates as available. Overall, I feel let down by Nokia, I have used the Iphone 3GS and HTC Hero. They are light years ahead in my opinion. Im sure Nokia will have great improvements to carry out via software updates throughout the next two years. But it doesnt change the build quality and finish. sorry for typo's. from steve
...
It was a really tough decision but I returned the N97. On top of my previously mentioned issues I began getting out of memory problems. This was around the time I became extremely busy at work and I didn't have the time to devote myself to the N97 to make it work. The N97 was a disappointment to me. It has great potential but I needed a phone for "now", not for something it could become in the future. I miss the N97 at times (am using the 3Gs right now) and was going to wait until next year to buy the N97 again once all its issues have been resolved. But with the N900 coming out soon I decided to go ahead and pre order it because it looks like what I hoped the N97 would be. I probably should have waited to see how it launches but patience was never one of my strong points. :-)
In my opinion
Thank you for the article, I am very interested in this topic. To enrich my knowledge, have read lots of books. By the way, if you are also interested in this issue, much useful info you may find with the help of a http://www.pdfqueen.com special pdf search engine .
Re:Memory card getting stuck, can u help???
18.3.2010 9:46
Subscribe to this comment's feed
